How Will Gen-Y Change the World: A Gen-Y Mini-Series (Part 2 of 5)

Yesterday we took an interesting look at how Millennials are drastically changing the consumer scene. The Gen-Y consumer is one based on lifestyle brands, which in itself is creating consumer horizontalization across all segments. To go along with this, Gen-Y is having an overwhelming effect on education and the workforce. And as we continue to explore and answer “how will Gen-Y change the world,” we will look at what these effects are causing not only to Gen-Y but the greater whole of society.

Gen-Y and the (De)value of Education

Education is a privilege, opportunity and experience few of us get to enjoy. It’s an absolute accomplishment and should never be taken for granted, especially in a world where only few get to truly enjoy it. And as powerful and important and necessary as education is, it seems to be taking on a dramatic turn in the Western world. Something that will seriously affect Gen-Y.

The value of education is extraordinary. And we’ve seen it’s positive impact across the globe for those who encounter it. For Gen-Y, education was the promise of a better life. “You’ll always have something to fall back on” or “get ready to start your career” and even all other opportunities that education historically offered are disappearing. As Gen-Y flocks to universities and colleges and as those organizations look to increase enrolment, the institution of education is increasingly devalued. And don’t be mistaken here, the education itself is still great and consistently carries the same educational value. The dilemma lies in the fact that having an education is simply not worth the same as before. And this will have profound effects.

As a Millennial myself with a Double Major Bachelor Degree and a Postgraduate Program Diploma, I can’t land a job. It’s ironic to think that after 5 years of solid education that no one is willing to hire me. This is a plague that all Gen-Y will have to endure. The global effects are even more overpowering. This means that as the rest of the world is trying to catch up in the simplest terms of providing education, we are entering an Era of the Masters Degree.

The Era of the Masters Degree

Education seemed to be the answer to getting a job before. Even the parents of Gen-Y believe this. As our Bachelor Degrees decline in value and we sit around waiting for jobs, two things occur: 1) we are enticed by our parents and ourselves to take further education or 2) we are enticed into pursuing the same level education but in a different category. This has caused the Era of the Masters Degree. As option 2 will just place you into the same boat as you currently are in, option 1 or pursuing the Masters Degree seems to be the right choice.

“Bachelors Degree required. Masters Degree preferred” is an increasingly used qualification that is beginning to trend, and something Millennials all cringe at seeing. What’s interesting with this is that you require higher levels of education for jobs that previously didn’t require it. What’s more interesting than that is the people that currently do that job or are hiring for it, don’t necessarily meet the qualifications themselves. I can almost see why Gen-Y feels they are entitled to more than they receive. And what’s even more interesting is the broader implications more education will have.

More Education = Less Work Experience

There is no doubt in my mind that the amount of Masters Degrees will increase considerably within Generation Y in comparison to previous generations. And I mean the numbers will be mind blowing, as anywhere at least between 15-25% of Gen-Y will graduate from a Masters program (note: I gathered this number from observations based on a variety of factors such # of job postings asking for, # of Gen-Y I’ve seen take on further education, and forecasting for the future). As Masters Degrees become more prevalent, we will see three implications begin to rise severely:

1) The amount of debt taken on by Gen-Y as a result of Bachelors education is quite large. To satisfy the Masters qualifications this debt will only increase. And this is only one of many debt issues Gen-Y will face.

2) The more education we receive the less work experience we gather. What’s interesting with this is that you need work experience to get a job but to get that experience you need a job. And on top of that you need higher education. It’s a catch-22 situation Gen-Y will constantly face.

3) There already seems to be a sense of joblessness as the ratio of graduates does not equal the amount of jobs available. As Gen-Y stays longer in school, they will face issues such as living at home longer and starting families later amongst other things.

Gen-Y will be more educated and less work experienced than any previous generation. As qualifications go up and jobs don’t equal the amounts of Gen-Y graduating (even as Baby Boomers retire many jobs are simply lost because they don’t exist anymore. Companies fail, jobs are lost, “we are doing more with less” are all aspects of jobs not equalling graduating Gen-Y even though Gen-Y will represent a serious number in the workforce in the next 5-8 years), we will see the entrepreneurial lifestyle emerge further. As a society, we will see education become increasingly commercialized. And the value of it will decline, as the Era of the Masters Degree looms. The fascinating and problematic issue is going to be whether previous generations are willingly to help us out or will we have to endure “that’s life” and “life is tough” responses. Maybe our best hope is in ourselves. Maybe Gen-Y will have bailout Gen-Y and fulfill our promises to a better life.

So stay tuned. If you haven’t read Part 1, I suggest you do. Otherwise, watch how Gen-Y is changing the world…

You might also like:

Share
Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

Agree with you on that Josip! Thanks for this interesting conversation.

Agree with you on that Josip! Thanks for this interesting conversation.

Great point Kapil! I like the example. And that example could be applied a countless number of different scenarios. The idea of transformation is an issue itself and tough that can be quite tough to crack. However, the issue of transformation is built on so many other issues. From dealing with issues of risk and change to the "almighty" dollar, transformation never happens fast enough for those who need. And it is happening too fast for those that oppose it.

As necessary as it is, it's a very unique topic in that hindsight is always perfect but our visions of the future are often blurred and feared, something of which is not by our own doing but rather something imposed onto us. It's unfortunate as transformation is often a ground-up movement and those that most need it will get it when its too late. However, when change is necessary the issue should never be put to rest no matter how hard it might be to overcome.

Josip, Thanks! You have highlighted some hard hitting facts... I agree on the fact that change and getting transformed is delicate and sometimes may backfire or not work! But if we don't make a move and take risks and try to change and transform then we might miss on a lot of innovation, knowledge and benefits.

To give you an example from India in the schools back in 90s, hardly couple of schools realized that a primary and basic level of education on computers was needed. Computers were treated as an optional subject and not part of the regular subjects. Later when the schools realized the growth and impact of computers in business, work and life only then did they make it part of their regular syllabus, but then it was too late. A huge set of students missed out on the opportunity of learning computers, instead these students were left with no other choice than to join private computers institutions to just have basic knowledge forget about industry specific courses. So with this kind of scenario its very important to transform and have a different approach so that people can have a better work career based on education.

Thanks for the comment Kapil and great to have you back! I do agree when you state that times are changing fast yet the institutions that we all rely on are not in fact transforming as quickly. The issue with this is that change is a delicate subject in many characteristics. And changing to something needs a really relevant thought process put behind it to be functional. So yes, our institutions are failing on us due to there lack of ability to change as fast as everything else. But in order for these institutions to change, we have to make the right decisions which in fact don't happen over night as much as we would've have liked.

I will take it one step further and say that these institutions are a fault for not seeing the future and adapting prior to the transformations taking place. As being the basis for all our education, one would think we all these educated minds we would be up to pace but now we find ourselves behind in many respects.

Great comment Barbara! I have to say that receiving a degree is great because of the education it delivers along with the experience you receive. However I would say as educated people goes up and as job demand goes up, we will see a future where more educated people won't be paid more. Ironic since in previous days educated people did receive greater earnings.

As by your recent estimates, I think it would actually take people longer than to pay off their education as wages won't grow due to greater job demand along with the combination of carrying debt longer and waiting for work. The fact of the matter is there isn't enough work for people that are being educated along with people that are being educated in fields that don't have work associated to them. As these problems increase, people will move away from education as a form of receiving greater earnings.

Also, I love your blog! Keep up the great work :)

Josip, Great Post!

I agree with your thoughts and facts. I think also that this story of Gen Y and Degrees varies a lot across countries. The point you have mentioned about having a degree and being jobless is also an age old problem in populated countries. However the bigger challenge is the content used for education. What a child learns for 12 or 20 years is almost outdated by the time child becomes adult and enters the real job or business world with a blank head and no clue whatsoever, this is true in current time, where everything is changing rapidly. So I think the educational and management institutions should take this into consideration and bring in some changes in the way they approach education.

There are companies who are hiring fresh talent as trainees on project basis, this gives them experience, and the company benefits from not paying a full time remuneration to them and gearing this individual for the next level. But I still agree with you that the percentage of such companies is very low and varies across countries...

I will be interested to know your thoughts on my latest blog. http://kapilpoojari.wordpress.com/2010/06/10/ge...

Hey Josip-- you've touched on a lot of truths here. The mad credentialing race, which an MA represents, has been going on for awhile. The well-educated have gotten super-educated. But where once the majority of advanced degree were in nonprofessional fields, today 85% are in practice-oriented fields like business and education. I'd venture that a lot (the majority?) of those MAs are not teaching any real skills, but are just a higher hurdle to enter the field.

But-- that said, over your lifetime, you'll earn a lot more than someone with just a community college degree or even just a BA (a person with a masters will earn $2.5 million over a lifetime of work. A person with an associate degree will earn $1.6m.) By recent estimates, even accounting for the time in school and thus not earning $$, a BA will pay off in 10 years of work (unless you go WAY into debt to get it). You just have to be strategic in where you go and how much debt you take on.

So, with numbers like that, I would say that a degree is still a good investment. I blog about these and all things young adult at mybarbararay.com

The consequences of issues like this can be quite drastic. I saw some numbers not too long ago, which show that youth unemployment is it's highest since its been since after WWII. What worries me is the financial implications of not having Gen-Y employed, especially after all the bailouts our generation will have to pay for.

And in the case of your sister, who's to say you can't work especially when we all have bills to pay. It's an odd state of affairs. One that has taken very harsh undertones.

Gen Y isn't supported enough. My sister used to live in Michigan and after she got her Master's in Communication at MSU, she applied for a basic secretary job, since Michigan is one of the most unemployed states in the US. The interviewer told her she was overqualified, and shouldn't be applying for that basic of a job! Very rude. I don't think someone can be overqualified. If they have the skills adequate enough to get the job done or even better and help earn profits for the company, then they would be a great hire!

~@Jskow1

Great comment Julie! I agree with you "no man's land" statement. Like you and many others, I've experienced either individuals telling me I don't have the years of experience for entry-level. However, I've also received the flip-side where I've been told that the "position" in question (which is entry level) wouldn't be for me. That I sound beyond entry-level and would be bored. In a sense I was over-qualified. If you don't get one excuse, you'll receive the next.

So when you say no man's land I understand the feeling. Though, its just a feeling. We'll all prevail. I just find it interesting that society is not willing to invest in us and what impact that will have literally everywhere.

Great blog post Josip!

I agree with the catch-22 statement! Trying to find an entry level marketing job was difficult, because everything I could find was 3-5 yrs experience needed in marketing. I couldn't figure out where do you get that 3-5 years of experience?

Seems like Gen Y is also stuck that if you get a Master's degree now, you can be "overqualified" to some employers. That's what my sister went through before, and I didn't want to go through that...it's scary. Along with this, and the other option of getting forced to get a Master's degree: sounds like no man's land!

You can check out my company's blog: http://whitingconsulting.wordpress.com

Great to have you back Ross and another great comment! I agree with you that education is "priceless and essential" and I'll throw in "important" and "necessary".

Life is a continuing shift from one point to the next. What matters is what happens while everything is shifting and Gen-Y will play an important role in that.

Do stay-tuned for the rest of the series :)

Josip - Another great post. I'm going to reveal my bias up front. I think education is priceless and essential! And I think a master's degree is unnecessary. Even today.

A lot of things have really shifted and will continue to shift. But only that - shift. Truth is, there's still plenty of money changing hands everyday. Where's it going? A lot of it is transferring, and will continue transfer, to small businesses and entrepreneurs. As a dovetail to your series here on how Gen Y will change the world, I think Gen Y is uniquely suited to take this ball and run with it. Either as entrepreneurs themselves or working for small biz. It can actually be more difficult to find these organizations but when you do they are incredible.

Gen Y (and everyone else) can get amazing education in small chunks with more practical application.

Looking forward to part 3...